Hulk: Collector's Edition (2003)

This review is sponsored by

BUY IT

General		Extras
Category	Science Fiction	Main Menu Introduction Menu Animation & Audio Audio Commentary-Ang Lee (Director) Active Subtitle Track-Hulk Cam: Inside The Rage DVD-ROM Extras Teaser Trailer-Thunderbirds Multiple Angles-Hulkification - 'You're Making Me Angry' Scene Featurette-Evolution Of The Hulk Featurette-The Incredible Ang Lee Featurette-Behind The Scenes-The Dog Fight Scene Featurette-The Unique Style Of Editing Hulk Featurette-Making Of-Cast and Crew, Stunts and Physical Effects, ILM, Music Deleted Scenes Featurette-Superhero Revealed: The Anatomy Of The Hulk (3D Model) Featurette-Behind The Scenes-Hulk The Lowdown Storyboards-Limited Edition Prints Of Unique Pieces Of StoryboardArtwork Booklet-Limited Edition Artwork Of The 'Hulkified' Scene (34 pages) Collector Card-The Incredible Hulk Marvel Comics #1 Reprint Booklet-Production Notes
Rating
Year Of Production	2003
Running Time	132:26
RSDL / Flipper	Dual Layered Multi Disc Set (3)	Cast & Crew
Start Up	Language Select Then Menu
Region Coding	2,4	Directed By	Ang Lee
Studio Distributor	Universal Pictures Home Video	Starring	Eric Bana Jennifer Connelly Nick Nolte Sam Elliott Josh Lucas
Case	?
RPI	$79.95	Music	Danny Elfman

Video		Audio
Pan & Scan/Full Frame	None	English Dolby Digital 5.1 (384Kb/s) English dts 5.1 (768Kb/s) English Audio Commentary Dolby Digital 2.0 (192Kb/s)
Widescreen Aspect Ratio	1.85:1
16x9 Enhancement
Video Format	576i (PAL)
Original Aspect Ratio	1.85:1	Miscellaneous
Jacket Pictures	No
Subtitles	English English for the Hearing Impaired Dutch English Audio Commentary Dutch Audio Commentary English Titling Active Subtitle Track	Smoking	No
		Annoying Product Placement	No
		Action In or After Credits	No

    The story begins by showing Bruce Banner's father (played well by Nick Nolte) working on human regeneration experiments in the army during the 1960s. Ordered not to perform tests on humans, he begins secretly experimenting on his own body. With the birth of his son, he becomes aware that he has transferred mutant genes that will ultimate change his son. Angered by being stopped from continuing his dangerous research into altering the human immune system, he starts a chain reaction of events that alters the path of his son's life. The story then picks up with Bruce (Eric Bana) working at a research institute with his ex-girlfriend Betty (the beautiful Jennifer Connelly). Their relationship is stalled, but it is obvious that both still have feelings for each other.

    The project that Bruce and Betty are working on deals with similar experiments to those his father conducted years before. Such research draws the attention of the sinister Talbot (Josh Lucas) and Betty's army general father (Sam Elliott). As expected, an accident in the lab unleashes the mutation initiated by the experimentation of Banner's father, who subtly works his way back into Bruce's life. The introduction of the Hulk is amazing to behold, and with the time allowed to develop the characters, by this stage you feel and care for Banner and his inner monster. Once the introduction is made, the pace quickens considerably, with some incredible action sequences, particularly the desert battle. Fortunately, there is still time to show the tender nature behind the Hulk, with a scene almost straight out of King Kong.

    The movie has a number of relationships that are explored: the tension between Betty and her father, the anger between Bruce and his father, and the tenderness between Betty and Bruce. Each is given proper time to develop and give us an understanding as to why the characters feel and act the way they do. Director Ang Lee could have fallen into the trap of wallowing too deeply in these relationships, but he never forgets that this is a comic book adaptation. The ending is perhaps the one letdown in the movie, and to me seems a little contrived and planned to accommodate the inevitable sequels, but this is only a minor issue with the strong acting and story more than making up for it.

    Lee uses some innovative (and at times confusing) editing techniques, including split-screen and various other unique ways of segueing one scene into another. Some people have complained about this technique, but I think it fits in perfectly with the comic book style, and adds a flair missing from other comic book adaptations. The CGI work on the Hulk has also been criticised, but I honestly cannot see what is at fault. At times the CGI is incredible (eg. the way Hulk dodges the ammunition as he rushes towards the tanks, the close-up facial expressions, and skin texture), and at all times blends in seamlessly with the live action around it.

    This 3-disc Collector's Edition release of Hulk contains the same 2 discs from the basic release with excellent quality video and audio transfers that will most definitely be demo material for the months ahead. A third disc containing a good documentary is also included, but this package is really only for die-hard fans. For everyone else, the 2-disc edition will more than suffice. The video and audio transfer descriptions below are taken from my initial review. The Extras section has been extended to include the third disc.

Video

    The movie is presented at an aspect ratio of 1.85:1, which matches the original theatrical ratio, and is 16x9 enhanced.

    The transfer throughout exhibits exceptional clarity and sharpness. There are some scenes early on that look particularly sharp against close-ups of plants and animals. Grain is undetectable in this transfer, even the intentional type, with white and stark backgrounds showing up as clear as I've ever seen. As expected, black levels are rock solid with not a hint of low level noise. Shadow detail needed to be spot-on too, especially in the dark introduction to the Hulk, and we are not let down. Detail is superb in both dark and bright scenes.

    Colours are sensational in the transfer, and are totally natural. For a comic book movie, there may have been a desire to go for too colourful and campy (eg. Dick Tracy) or slightly muted (eg. X-Men). However, the colours in Hulk are perfect, with no colour bleeding or over-saturation. I could not detect any posterization in the transfer. I could not detect any edge enhancement being applied to this transfer.

    I counted only one film artefact throughout the movie, that being a solitary white fleck on the screen for but a frame. Due to the sharpness of the transfer, aliasing does crop up on a couple of occasions accompanied by some moiré effects. The most prominent example is at 11:45, as Banner talks to his colleague with the horizontally striped shirt. As the man moves, the shirt shimmers and exhibits moiré effects. Aliasing occurs on some blinds and railings too, but isn't distracting.

    This is an RSDL-formatted disc, with the layer change perfectly placed in a fade-to-black scene with no sound. It occurs at 68:20 and is all but indiscernible.

    In short, Hulk scrubs up very well with this sensational video transfer.

Video Ratings Summary

Sharpness
Shadow Detail
Colour
Grain/Pixelization
Film-To-Video Artefacts
Film Artefacts
Overall

Audio

    Dialogue throughout is crystal clear with no audio synchronisation or bad ADR problems.

    The musical score by Danny Elfman is great, and captures the mood of each scene perfectly. It is mixed into each speaker cleverly, with some very nice panning effects across the soundstage in a similar manner to that used in The Bourne Identity. Of particular note is the start of the musical cue at 94:03, as the score beat circles around you, totally drawing you into the battle that ensues in the desert.

    Of course, surround activity is not restricted to supporting the music. Panning and overhead effects abound, and all manner of Foley and other effects come across clear as a bell from all speakers. The soundstage is completely enveloping, from the major action set pieces to the quieter moments (eg. as Betty goes out in the dark to check the bump in the night).

    The subwoofer certainly has its work cut out for it with this audio transfer. It is used in a subtle manner to support effects such as heartbeats and gamma bombs, while in other areas it is used to its maximum house-rumbling best to support other explosions and general Hulk devastation. The sequence around 93:15 as he escapes from army detention exhibits some of the best subwoofer use that I have come across.

    I listened to the DTS track in its entirety and compared it against the Dolby Digital track in some key sequences. For example, the sequence indicated above highlighted the slight superiority of the DTS track in its more refined use of bass and the higher clarity and spaciousness of the surround soundstage. The DTS track is encoded louder than the Dolby Digital track, but even when compensating for this volume difference, the Dolby Digital track cannot really match the DTS track. This is not to say that the Dolby Digital track is bad, because it is still better than many other Dolby Digital tracks out there (and many DTS tracks for that matter).

Audio Ratings Summary

Dialogue
Audio Sync
Clicks/Pops/Dropouts
Surround Channel Use
Subwoofer
Overall

    Extra material is provided on all three discs in this DVD release, with most being of decent quality. Discs 1 and 2 are identical to the original release.

Disc 1:

Director's Commentary - Ang Lee

    Director Ang Lee talks through his ideas and visions when confronted with the making of Hulk. He describes his own life views, and does tend to digress a little and then come back and relate what he has said to the movie. At times it is difficult to understand what he has said due to his accent. Overall, this is a fairly interesting commentary, but it does tend to drag a bit.

Hulk-Cam - Inside the Rage

    This feature is similar to the White Rabbit feature on The Matrix DVD where an icon will appear on the screen during the movie to allow you to skip into behind-the-scenes footage. It is convenient that the DVD allows you to skip forward to the exact spot that the features present themselves on the screen. In total there are eleven little featurettes before particular scenes that map out the preparation of that scene. The icon appears at:

• 28:14 - before the accident scene, showing the cast and crew preparing the lab for the scene.
• 35:52 - before the meeting between Betty and her father.
• 40:40 - before Banner morphs into Hulk for the first time, showing how they destroyed the lab and then digitally composited the CGI Hulk into the scene. It is amazing how much effort went into measuring and aligning the frame exactly so that the plate photography could then be used by the CGI animators.
• 56:18 - before the morphing scene at the house, showing Bana and Lucas rehearsing the flight scene.
• 56:57 - before Hulk exits the house to find Betty showing the stunt men and the preparation for the front of the house being blown away.
• 89:22 - before he escapes from army detention, showing the preparation of the set for his escape.
• 93:03 - before the explosion at the house after the escape, showing the setup of the house explosion.
• 93:43 - before he rolls down the sand dunes, showing footage of the motion capture actors in action.
• 106:13 - before Hulk arrives underground in the San Francisco area, showing the setup of the traffic crash scene.
• 108:42 - before Betty calms the Hulk down, showing footage of the extras and the police actors.
• 113:43 - before the scene with his father, showing Bana and Nolte in rehearsal.

DVD-ROM Features

    For some reason, I could not access any DVD-ROM features using my computer.

Thunderbirds Teaser Trailer

    The short teaser trailer shows one of the Thunderbird spacecraft landing in London.

Disc 2:

Hulkification

    This is a nice extra that shows the artwork provided by four different comic book artists for their interpretation of the flight and morphing scene at the house. Biographies of the artists are also provided. The artwork can either be shown on its own or with the footage from the movie side-by-side. The artists are:

• Adam Kubert - a very typical US comic style with nice colour.
• Tommy Ohtsuka - Japanese style artwork that almost resembles Dragonball Z with weird hairstyles and noses.
• Salvador Larooca - follows the movie almost to the scene, and I suspect this is the comic adaptation of the movie.
• Katsuya Terada - another Japanese artist, this time far more darker and sinister in its style.

Evolution of The Hulk - 16:18

    A documentary (presented full-frame) about the origin and conception of the Hulk and the comic book series. Describes in quite a bit of detail the past history of Marvel comics and the 60s that brought us other heroes such as the X-Men, Daredevil, and The Fantastic Four. It was interesting to hear how Stan Lee merged the concepts of Frankenstein and Dr Jekyll/Mr Hyde into the Hulk.

The Incredible Ang Lee - 14:29

    A featurette showing interviews with both cast and crew gushing over how brilliant and amazing working with Ang Lee is. Also includes Ang describing his vision of the Hulk, and his direction of the cast.

The Dog Fight Scene - 10:10

    A featurette showing the preparation and making of the dog fight scene. Shows actual footage of the initial meeting between Ang and the ILM staff. It is incredible that the original storyboards of the sequence had to be almost trimmed to a quarter of its size due to the enormous cost. As it stood, the sequence in the movie cost $16 million alone.

The Unique Style of Editing Hulk - 5:35

    A short featurette describing the use of the very innovative editing style, with the use of split screens and other CG transition effects.

The Making of Hulk - 23:45

    This featurette is broken into four parts:

• Cast & Crew - The typical "it's so great to be working with all these great actors and directors" featurette.
• Stunts and Physical Effects - shows the behind the scenes footage of all the on-set stunts and effects (eg. explosions and stuntmen being tossed around).
• ILM - shows the concept paintings, models, and CGI work produced by ILM. These guys are seriously talented.
• Music - shows the orchestra recording the musical score composed by Danny Elfman.

Deleted Scenes

    Shows a number of deleted scenes one after another. The deleted scenes include:

• Betty and Bruce giving the presentation that they talk about at the beginning of the movie. I am glad they took this out, because the scene certainly gets bogged down in unnecessary scientific mumbo-jumbo.
• Bruce talking to Betty on the phone about her dreams.
• a college flashback showing Bruce having an attack.
• short scene with a conversation between Betty's father and the mayor of San Francisco.
• an extra cameo appearance by Lou Ferrigno.
• a scene showing security people moving things out of Betty's house.

DVD-ROM Features

    For some reason, I could not access any DVD-ROM features using my computer.

Super Hero Revealed - The Anatomy of the Hulk

    A strange extra that resembles a kid's educational tool. From this extra you can select different body parts from a rotating image of the Hulk and display some trivia about that body part. There is also the option to view some ILM facts and animation as well.

Disc 3:

Hulk - The Lowdown - 43:25

    This is the sole extra feature on the third disc. The documentary presented here at an aspect ratio of 1.85:1 (non-16x9 enhanced) is fairly good, with a decent mix of new footage and rehashed material from Disc 1 and 2. The program is hosted by Sam Elliott and Josh Lucas, with Elliott focusing on the CGI work by ILM and Lucas focusing on the on-set behind the scenes footage.

    The most fascinating part of this documentary was the additional footage of director Ang Lee putting on the motion capture suit and providing the performance of the Hulk, both for the violent destruction scenes to the more intricate facial expressions. It was fascinating to see Ang playing out the scene where Hulk smashes the tanks, and seeing that they pretty much used his performance completely.

    Although this documentary is good, it certainly doesn't justify the price increase from the 2-disc release. I believe this 3-disc Collector's Edition is only for die-hard fans of the Hulk who want to get the special packaging and memorabilia that comes with this 3-disc package.

    It would appear from my research that Region 1 does not even have a 3-disc Collector's Edition, unless my searches on the Internet are way off the mark. I simply could not find any reference to it in Region 1. This surprises me, so if anyone knows of a Region 1 3-disc Collector's Edition, let me know.

    Hulk is a great movie, let down perhaps by a forced ending paving the way to a sequel. Being of a more serious nature than other recent comic book adaptations, this approach worked well in portraying the inner turmoil and drama behind Bruce Banner and his inner monster. With exceptional digital effects, solid acting, innovative editing, and a good script, I thoroughly enjoyed Hulk at the box office. With sensational video and audio transfers that will delight on DVD, the original 2-disc release is a must-have for all comic book fans (and probably those that are not, too). The addition of the third disc provides a good documentary, but does not really justify the price increase on its own. This 3-disc edition is for die-hard fans wanting the special packaging and the memorabilia that comes with it.

    The video quality is sensational, being extremely clear, sharp and detailed.

    The audio quality is equally sensational, with the DTS option being the soundtrack of choice.

    The extras are informative and provide a good insight into the level of effort put into making such a movie.

Video
Audio
Extras
Plot
Overall